Civilisations · 20 April 2026

Dante Put the Pope in Hell — The Divine Comedy

Dante Alighieri - The Divine Comedy

🖼️ Illustrated edition
Illustration for Dante Put the Pope in Hell — The Divine Comedy

Title: The Divine Comedy Author: Dante Alighieri Creation Date: 1308-1321 Location: Italy

Summary

Dante's poem follows the pilgrim Dante through the three realms of the afterlife — Inferno, Purgatorio, and Paradiso — guided first by the Roman poet Virgil and then by Beatrice, the woman he loved. Across one hundred cantos in terza rima, the journey moves from the depths of Hell's concentric circles, through the terraces of Purgatory, to the celestial spheres of Paradise, culminating in a direct vision of God. The poem is simultaneously a personal spiritual autobiography, a compendium of medieval theology and philosophy, and a savage political commentary on the Florence and Italy of Dante's day.

Why This Book Matters

The Divine Comedy is arguably the single most important literary work of medieval Europe. It synthesised the entire intellectual inheritance of the Western Middle Ages — Aristotelian philosophy, Thomistic theology, classical mythology, Provençal love poetry, and Florentine politics — into one unified vision. More than a theological treatise in verse, it established Italian as a literary language capable of matching Latin, and in doing so helped invent the very idea of a national literature written in the vernacular. Every subsequent European poet, from Petrarch to T.S. Eliot, has written in its shadow.

Historical Context

Dante composed the Comedy during his exile from Florence (1302–1321), a period of intense factional warfare between Guelphs and Ghibellines, and within the Guelphs between Black and White factions. The poem reflects the broader crisis of the late medieval world: the clash between papal and imperial authority, the rise of mercantile city-states, and the intellectual ferment as Aristotle's works filtered back into Europe through Arabic translations. Dante wrote in the Florentine vernacular rather than Latin — a radical choice that would reshape European literature.

Literary Significance

The terza rima verse form (ABA BCB CDC) was Dante's invention, creating a forward-driving chain of interlocking rhymes that mirrors the pilgrim's relentless progress. The poem's architecture — 3 canticles of 33 cantos each, plus one introductory canto, yielding 100 total — reflects a medieval numerological perfection. But what makes the Comedy endure as literature rather than artefact is Dante's psychological realism: the damned souls of Inferno, from Francesca da Rimini to Count Ugolino, are rendered with a specificity and empathy that anticipates the novel by centuries.

Research Notes

The Divine Comedy is non-negotiable for any European literature canon. The Hollander translation preserves scholarly apparatus and literal fidelity; Mandelbaum captures the poetry more fluidly for general readers. Clive James's 2013 verse translation is a notable recent alternative. The poem's length and density make it challenging but its episodic structure (individual cantos function as self-contained scenes) makes it surprisingly accessible in portions.

The Reading

Midway in the journey of our life I came to myself inside a dark wood, the straight way lost. I had left the true path so full of sleep that I remember no turning: trees savage and dense, and a fear that comes back whenever I bring the place to mind. I was thirty-five, and my name is Dante, of the Alighieri, of Florence — a city that spent my lifetime tearing at itself, Guelf against Ghibelline, and then, the Guelfs having won, tearing itself in half again. Two years after the night I am about to describe, the winning half sentenced me to burn if I came back inside the walls. I set this down from other men's houses, and there is nothing in it I mean to soften.

I saw a hill ahead with the morning light on its shoulders and began to climb. A leopard came first, light and quick and spotted. Behind it a lion with its head held high, and behind the lion a she-wolf, gaunt with a hunger nothing had ever satisfied, who drove me back down towards the place where the sun is silent.

Dante lost in the dark wood, the leopard, lion and she-wolf prowling between the trees and the distant sunlit hill beyond.
Dante lost in the dark wood, the leopard, lion and she-wolf prowling between the trees and the distant sunlit hill beyond.

As I fell back, a figure stood in the emptiness before me, faint, like one grown hoarse from long silence. He had been born in Mantua under Julius, had written in Rome under the good Augustus, and had sung of Aeneas. It was Virgil, whose pages I had worn thin, and I begged him to save me from the beast.

The she-wolf lets no man past, he said. There was another road: down first, through an eternal place where I would hear the shrieks of the hopeless, then up a mountain of penitents — and beyond that, being born outside the faith, he could not go. A lady in Heaven had wept over my danger and called Lucia, and Lucia had gone to Beatrice: Bice Portinari, whom I had loved since I was nine years old, who died in the summer of 1290 at twenty-four, and who had come down into Limbo herself to ask him. Three women in Heaven had moved on my account while I stood shivering on a slope. I told him to lead.

The shade of Virgil in his Roman robes appearing on the wooded slope to the stricken pilgrim Dante.
The shade of Virgil in his Roman robes appearing on the wooded slope to the stricken pilgrim Dante.

Inferno

The words above the gate were cut in a dark colour. Through me the way into the suffering city; through me the way among the lost people. "Abandon all hope, you who enter here." Virgil told me to leave every cowardice at the door, and took my hand.

The two small figures of Dante and Virgil before the colossal stone gate of Hell, its Latin inscription cut deep across the lintel.
The two small figures of Dante and Virgil before the colossal stone gate of Hell, its Latin inscription cut deep across the lintel.

In the second ring of Hell, a black gale blows without pause and never lets the souls in it rest. Two came down the wind together and would not separate even for me. Francesca da Rimini had loved Paolo, her husband's brother. Love, she said, is quickly kindled in a gentle heart, and it absolves no one who is loved from loving in return. They had been reading of Lancelot and Guinevere; and when they came to the place where the lover kisses the queen, he who will never now be parted from me kissed my mouth, all trembling. That day we read no further. Paolo wept the whole time she spoke, and the pity took my senses, and I fell as a dead body falls.

Francesca and Paolo entwined in flight on the great dark whirlwind of the Second Circle, Dante swooning at the cliff edge.
Francesca and Paolo entwined in flight on the great dark whirlwind of the Second Circle, Dante swooning at the cliff edge.

Far down, where the ground is bare sand and fire comes out of the sky in slow flakes, there are souls never allowed to stop walking. One ran at me sideways out of the troop and caught the hem of my gown, and through the scorched crust of that face I knew him: Brunetto Latini, who had taught me how a man makes himself eternal. He would not let me come down to him, so I walked the bank above him with my head bowed. He told me what my city would do to me: both its parties would be hungry for me, and I should keep clear of both. If you follow your star, he said, you cannot fail of a glorious port.

Lower again, in the ditches where the frauds are kept, the false counsellors burn one to a flame. The largest was split at the tip, and Ulysses spoke out of it. Not fondness for his son, he said, nor duty to his old father, nor the love he owed Penelope could quiet in him the longing to know the world. He went out past the Pillars of Hercules with one ship and the handful who had not left him, and told them to consider the seed they sprang from: you were not made to live like brutes, but to follow virtue and knowledge. Five months west and south, a mountain rose out of the water. They cheered, and the cheering turned to weeping, because a whirlwind came off that mountain and the sea closed over them, as pleased Another.

Ulysses imprisoned within a single tongue of flame, speaking to Dante and Virgil on the rim of the eighth ditch.
Ulysses imprisoned within a single tongue of flame, speaking to Dante and Virgil on the rim of the eighth ditch.

At the bottom there is a lake of ice, and the traitors are set into it. I saw two heads frozen in one hole, the upper feeding on the lower, and asked him why. Count Ugolino lifted his mouth from that head and wiped it on the hair. Archbishop Ruggieri had him shut in the tower with his sons and his grandsons, the youngest a child. He heard the door of that tower being nailed shut below them, and looked at his sons' faces and did not weep, because he had turned to stone inside. When no food came, they understood, and one of them said: Father, it will hurt us far less if you eat us. So he held himself still, so as not to make them sadder. They died one by one, each calling to him. He was blind by then, and went over their bodies with his hands for two days after, calling to each in turn. Then fasting had more power than grief. He put his teeth back into the skull.

At the centre of everything stands the Emperor of that woeful kingdom, out of the ice to mid-chest, three faces on one head, six wings beating, and it is the wind of those wings that keeps the whole lake frozen. He chews three men in three mouths: Judas headfirst, Brutus and Cassius on either side. There is no majesty in him — a great deal of machinery, and no mind behind it, and the thing at the bottom of the world turns out to be a vacancy.

The colossal three-headed Satan embedded to the waist in the frozen lake of Cocytus, each mouth gnawing a traitor.
The colossal three-headed Satan embedded to the waist in the frozen lake of Cocytus, each mouth gnawing a traitor.

We climbed down him by the hair, and at his hip Virgil turned round and began to climb what had been the way down: we had passed the point to which all weight is drawn. We followed a stream up through the rock, and came out to see the stars again.

Dante and Virgil emerging from a narrow rocky cleft onto an open shore beneath a vast night sky scattered with stars.
Dante and Virgil emerging from a narrow rocky cleft onto an open shore beneath a vast night sky scattered with stars.

Purgatorio

Dawn on that shore was the colour of sapphire. Cato, who chose death at Utica over Caesar, keeps the foot of the mountain; he sent us down to wash Hell off my face and bind me with a rush, the plant that bends and does not break.

The conical mountain of Purgatory rising out of the southern sea at dawn, a small angel-piloted boat of arriving souls approaching its shore.
The conical mountain of Purgatory rising out of the southern sea at dawn, a small angel-piloted boat of arriving souls approaching its shore.

Below the gate there is a whole country of waiting. Manfred, who had been king in Sicily, showed me the wound over his brow and the one in his breast, and told me how at the last he gave himself back weeping to the One who pardons willingly. Horrible were my sins, he said, but infinite goodness has arms so wide that it takes whatever turns to it — and the bishop who dug up his bones and threw them out along the river had not read that page. Higher up, Belacqua sat hugging his knees, and asked what the use was of going up before his time. I woke at the gate itself, carried there by Lucia while I slept, and the angel cut seven P's into my forehead, one for each sin, to be wiped off as I climbed.

Above the gate the mountain is a school. Every terrace takes one crooked love and straightens it by making the soul do the opposite of what it did in life, and none of it is punishment, because every soul there is there by consent. The proud go bent double under stones until they learn to look up.

A long line of bent souls in plain robes labouring up the terrace of the proud, each crushed double beneath an enormous boulder.
A long line of bent souls in plain robes labouring up the terrace of the proud, each crushed double beneath an enormous boulder.

In the smoke of the wrathful, Marco Lombardo answered the question I had carried the whole way up. If the world has gone wrong, is the cause in the stars? The heavens begin your motions, he said, not all of them: a light is given you to know good from evil, and a free will that conquers if it survives its first battles. The fault is in you. Further up, where the avaricious lie face down in the dust, the mountain shook and every soul on it cried Gloria in excelsis: Statius, loose after twelve hundred years, coming up to join us, and not knowing the man walking beside him. Through you I was a poet, he said when I gave the name, and through you a Christian: you went by night with the light behind you, no use to yourself, and those who came after saw by it.

At the top terrace a wall of fire crosses the whole path, and there is no way up except through it. I stood with my hands locked and would not move. Then he said: between Beatrice and you there is now only this wall. So I went in, and he walked ahead of me the whole way talking about her eyes. On the far side he spoke his last words to me as guide. You have come where I can discern no further of myself. Take your own pleasure for your guide from here. Your will is free, upright and whole. Therefore over yourself I crown and mitre you.

At the summit is the garden that was made for us and that we lost. A woman gathering flowers on the far bank — Matelda — told me the water divides: Lethe takes away the memory of what one has done wrong, Eunoe gives back the memory of every good. Then the wood filled with light and a procession came down that bank, elders crowned with lilies, a chariot drawn by a griffin. Angels threw flowers by the handful, and inside that cloud a woman appeared, veiled in white, crowned with olive, in a dress the colour of live flame.

I could not see her face and I knew her anyway. The old love came back on me with all its old force, and I turned to my left to say to Virgil what a frightened child turns and says to its mother — not a drop of blood is left in me that is not trembling. And Virgil was not there. Virgil, sweetest father, Virgil to whom I had given myself up for my salvation, had gone while I was looking the other way, and had not said goodbye, and my washed cheeks went black again with tears. Dante, she said — and my own name was the first word she spoke to me — do not weep yet for Virgil going. Weep for another sword than that. Look at me well. I am indeed Beatrice.

She would not be gentle. While she was alive she had held me straight with nothing but her face. The day she crossed into her second life I had turned to somebody else and gone down roads that were not roads, and had sunk so far that nothing was left except to show me the lost people. She made me say it out loud, and I got out that as soon as her face was hidden, present things with their false pleasure had turned my steps aside — and then I broke down entirely and fell. I came to in the river with Matelda holding my head, drawn through Lethe; and on the far bank they asked her to unveil her mouth, and she did.

Beatrice crowned with olive leaves on a chariot drawn by a griffin, meeting Dante across the river Lethe in the Earthly Paradise.
Beatrice crowned with olive leaves on a chariot drawn by a griffin, meeting Dante across the river Lethe in the Earthly Paradise.

Paradiso

The glory of Him who moves all things penetrates the universe and shines in one part more and in another less. I have been in the heaven that takes most of His light, and I saw things there which no one who comes down from that place knows how to tell, because the mind goes so deep that memory cannot follow it back.

Beatrice looked at the sun longer than an eagle could, and I looked at her looking, and we were rising. The first souls I met were the faintest, and one was Piccarda Donati, whose brother had taken her out of her convent by force and married her off. I asked whether she wished she were higher up. She smiled at me as at a child who has not been attending. Charity quiets the will here, she said, and leaves us wanting only what we have; and in His will is our peace.

Higher, in Mars, the souls of those who died for the faith are set out in a cross of light, and a flame came down that cross to me the way a star crosses a clear night: Cacciaguida, my own great-great-grandfather, dead on crusade. He described the Florence he had known inside its old walls, sober and at peace, its women at the spindle telling stories of Troy and Rome, no house yet emptied out by exile.

The countless blessed souls forming an enormous luminous cross of light in the sphere of Mars, Dante and Beatrice tiny against it.
The countless blessed souls forming an enormous luminous cross of light in the sphere of Mars, Dante and Beatrice tiny against it.

Then I asked him for what everyone from Hell upward had been hinting at, and he gave it plainly. I would leave behind everything I loved most dearly, and that is the first arrow the bow of exile shoots. I would learn how salt another man's bread tastes, and how hard a road it is going up and down another man's stairs. And when I said I was afraid to write what I had seen, because the truth would shut every door that might otherwise open to me, he told me to put away every falsehood and make the whole vision plain. This cry of mine, he said, would do what the wind does, striking hardest at the highest summits — and that would be no small argument of my honour.

Before the last ascent she told me to look back down at the earth, the little threshing floor that makes us so fierce. Then we came out of space and time altogether into light: intellectual light, full of love; love of the true good, full of joy. A river of it ran between banks of impossible spring, and when I drank it with my eyes the river turned into a circle and showed itself as it was — rank upon rank of the blessed in the petals of an enormous white rose, with angels going down into it and up out of it like bees.

The vast celestial white rose of the Empyrean, tier upon tier of luminous blessed souls petalled around a central radiant point of the Trinity.
The vast celestial white rose of the Empyrean, tier upon tier of luminous blessed souls petalled around a central radiant point of the Trinity.

I turned to ask her about it and an old man was standing where she had been. She had gone up to her own seat in the rose, and I said across that distance that she had drawn me out of slavery, that she had gone down and left her footprints in Hell for my sake, and that whatever I had seen I owed to her. She looked down at me, and smiled, and turned back to the eternal fountain.

The old man was Bernard, who had spent his life on the Virgin. He showed me Mary at the summit of the rose, and prayed to her on my behalf, since my sight would have to be made stronger or I would see nothing at all. Virgin mother, daughter of your son, humble and higher than any creature — scatter every cloud of his mortality, so that the highest joy can open in front of him. She looked up.

And I looked. My sight went into the light and was taken up by it. I saw the scattered leaves of the whole universe bound into one volume by love. I saw three circles of three colours and one size. And in the second, painted in its own colouring, I saw our image; and I strained at how it could be there as a geometer strains at the circle and never finds the principle he needs. Then my mind was struck by a flash that gave it what it wanted, and my power failed there. But my desire and my will were already turning, evenly, like a wheel that is moved smoothly, by the Love that moves the sun and the other stars.


This post is part of Civilisations, a 149-book chronological journey through world literature. See the full collection →


The two standard English translations are Robert and Jean Hollander's (Anchor, 2000–2007), which preserves scholarly apparatus and literal fidelity, and Allen Mandelbaum's (Bantam/Everyman's Library, 1980–1984), which captures the poetry more fluidly for general readers.

By Dante Alighieri, translated by Robert and Jean Hollander. The authoritative scholarly translation — literal, extensively annotated, includes the Italian text.

By Dante Alighieri, translated by Allen Mandelbaum. All three canticles in a single volume — the most poetically accessible rendering for general readers.


Disclaimer: some links in this post are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Editions

  • The Divine Comedy

    Unknown · 2000 · paperback · English

    By Dante Alighieri, translated by Robert and Jean Hollander. The authoritative scholarly translation — literal, extensively annotated, includes the Italian text.

    View on Amazon →
  • The Divine Comedy

    Unknown · 2000 · paperback · English

    By Dante Alighieri, translated by Allen Mandelbaum. All three canticles in a single volume — the most poetically accessible rendering for general readers.

    View on Amazon →

Amazon links are affiliate links. Purchases made through these links support History in Books at no extra cost to you.

civilisationsworld literaturemedieval literatureItalian literatureclassicsfaith and philosophyillustrated edition